Suggestion Title: Go PrivateShort Description: Create 1 or 2 big (popular) modpack servers for the public and keep the rest private behind a donator wall.Long Description: Mojang can only enforce their policies on public servers. so give them what they want. Make 1 or more servers, free for all to play on, but no perks what-so-ever. Nothing that can conflict with mojang EULA crap and "fair" for everybody who plays there. Create a private part (on the forums or so) where people who agree to a small donation (or buy a rank) can join all the other modded servers you have had going for the last couple of years. Maybe revamp the patron rank (make it cheaper, so its actually less of an issue for people to buy it) and use that to give people who want to pay to play, full access to everything (except ofcourse for the public ones, or only if they dont mind playing perk-less on those public ones). Im not entirely sure on the numbers, but there are thousands of modded servers out there that Mojang doesnt or cant touch, mainly because they are private servers. It seems that if you run privately, you can do pretty much anything you like without them doing jack sh*t about it. Lastly about your costs, you mentioned you are barely breaking even. Maybe go 100% pay to play (not pay to win, but pay to play). Divide server upkeep and whatnot, by the amount of active players per server and tell them that unless they donate a certain amount of money a month, the server will not be running for much longer. Im certain that if costs are low enough per player, all your regular and loyal players, will chip in. Heck... even being a cheapskate myself, i probably would if it wouldnt cost more than 3-5 euro's a month. And if there are players who dont like to pay in order for you to keep your servers up and running, deny them access to certain servers and limit them to only 1 or 2 packs untill they comply and pay for server upkeep like everybody else who contributes. Or make a donation page, where you state the total running costs of your entire network as a big number with a huge honking donation button below it. Do it like twitch does it. Keep a list of top contributors and if they really stand out by their donation, reward them with a goodie, like a t-shirt from mym or something else silly. TL;DR Version: Go private servers. Use a pay-wall to give exclusive access to your modded servers for paying members only. Or make a donation page and use the donation system like twitch does it with their streamers. Also lower the amount every player would have to contribute based on the active amount of players/contributors. Lower costs per player will likely increase the chance that they will actually contribute.