When I use /island restart it only deletes about a 20x20 area of the island, which means anything past that from my previous island is still there. How can I get a full restart on my island?
Have you tried teleporting to spawn and back or to logout and back in to see if it will delete the remaining?
Its normally just a graphic glitch where the blocks delete but takes restarting to get them off the screen. Glad I could help.