[CIV] Market Restrictions

It has been brought up that their might be a good reason to implement market restrictions on CIV.

This thread is to determine if an End-Game Item list for market restrictions is wanted.

As of right now, the only restriction on CIV is, (And regardless of this poll will always be):

• Bees: Only world drop bees
• Seeds: If it says agricraft on it, you can't sell it.

As always we will leave this open for 7 days, and if you don't post why, I won't count your vote.

Spoiler: --- Personal Opinion---

No, I feel that we do not need a market restriction on CIV. I like the way that it is, and I dont see people flooding the market with super cheap items

 

My personal opinion on the matter, is that I feel restricting the market can be beneficial in a way as to avoid people reaching that end game stat, because I believe it should be a challenge, I understand people my disagree, however, simply my opinion

 

I've never understood the need to regulate how people enjoy the game. It's not a competition, so there's no unfair situation if someone wants to buy end game stuff and skip ahead. Nobody is harmed, except those that feel that their enjoyment was decreased because someone else didn't have to "work" as much as they did.

It's a game, and the end goal of the server should be to accommodate people's play styles and game choices, if it doesn't create an unfair situation and nobody is harmed. I just don't see any harm, or real disadvantage other than perceived, to any other players if two people can arrive at an equitable trade of goods that both are happy with.

 

tbh its quite nice being able to put things on the mark et and having more stuff that is selleble will allow myms to flow between players more freely plus i dont know many people that under price goods as long as its not from thaum or botania where there is strick progression

 

In my opinion market restrictions just dont fit the theme of civilisation. For modpacks like this less rules = more fun.. in the end its pvp, if you are not ready for stuff you illegitimately obtain, there is a good chance to lose it again

 

In my opinion I think that the market should be open to as many items including some end items as people selling earn money for there hard work and people buying have less work on there hands and everyone happy.

 

IMHO restrict some end-game items will allow player to actually continue the progress of some mods. Many(if not all) of the mods on Civ are based on progression, in creating things and earning them.

As of right now, people can sell raw items to help the progression of such mods (bottled essentia, Living rock, Mekanism/Ender IO parts, clay botles and fumes rom witchery).

But in the end, i'm not against a "free market", I just prefere a regulated one.

 

I am not against a free market i actually like the idea. I would't like to see the sell of endgame items at a ridiculous low price imo

 

I simply wanted an endgame list because I was tired of being told what I couldn't trade. With the option though I prefer Open Market,no endgame list, without the market plugin. I would free a village where players can build shops, trade items instead of the market.

 

Actually... the idea of @Arcanuo is great

 

Let me flesh it out a bit, one second.[DOUBLEPOST=1455027323][/DOUBLEPOST]Trade Village:

An Admin claimed land deposit beside spawn, with multiple sub-claims that can be rented for X MyMs per week. A form of shop plugin that supports modded IDs woould needed. This area would also be a no PvP zone but only be accessible from spawn.

Pros:

- realistic
- Allows the trading of high tier endgame items but balances it because they have to visit the market, and actually purchase or haggle.

Cons:
- Could run out of plots.

 

\
chest shop supports ids but not things like tinkers tools

 

Not everything needs to be sell in chest shop ever hear about making a sign describing it and selling it without the shop hehe

 

i feel we need market restrictions, because on the market players who just started can buy things that took me hours of work to get. I think this isnt fair for players that are already long on the server.

 

Again if they bought it don't worry they are the ones spoiling their fun

 

I think there should be restriction on trading items giving players direct pvp advantage (heart canisters, armor, weapons...). If there weren't those restrictions the pvp aspect will be heavily imbalanced (trading KAMI items).
And what will be even worse will be greater amount of players whining about getting one shotted outside their claims and losing their items when they first took agressive stance (Yes, this happened, even when there were no rules broken.).

 

Find this and I'll look into making it happen. It will need to support modded items with either the actual name, or a picture (Name is preferred). Also will need to support a blacklist.

 

Why work hard to achieve an item when u can buy it

 

I really feel like we don't need restrictions on the market

 

I must say I'm finding this interesting to see people's takes on it